nostr is intended to be:
The simplest open protocol that is able to create a censorship-resistant global “social” network once and for all.
This looks like a promising foundation for the ideal social network!
How nostr fits
- easy to extend
- public key identities
- key exchange happens outside of the protocol
- simple client/relay architecture
- simple message format
- relays and clients for major platforms
- seed phrase key generation and key paths (NIP-06)
Concerns about nostr
Mass adoption of nostr in its current form may not result in a decentralized architecture.
- relays are controlled by untrusted entities, creating a power imbalance
- relays may become expensive to operate, encouraging rent-seeking and increasing centralization
- relies on DNS registrars
- relies on TLS certificate authorities
For nostr to qualify as the ideal social network, following changes can be implemented:
- users run their own relays, giving them derivative keys which they use to encrypt all data
- users only connect to their own relays, which in turn only connect to the relays of their direct contacts
This will ensure all users of nostr are equals, keep the cost of relays low, remove the use of DNS and TLS, and allow secure communication between relays and clients (rather than only clients and clients).
If this was adopted, the barrier to using nostr would be much higher, because relays are much more difficult to run than clients.
This means the popularity of nostr would depend on making it as easy as possible to run a relay.
Since one of the main goals of this project is to implement the ideal social network, we’ll give it a try!